My question was specifically about the Black Market's bag, as in what would you expect to see there?
Many of the things you've listed have been and will be available by other means, that are not limited to the Black Market or don't rely on a chance-based mechanic like the bags.
"
Have Been" being the key term..
The V'day things were only available in 2014
The Winter items were only available in 2015
The cookies haven't been available since 2020
Dusky Potion - Halloween Shop 2015
Bone Venom - Halloween Shop 2016
Poison Fang - a drink at Remy's 2018
Pumpkin Carving Kit - Halloween Shop 2020
The other things have been available more recently, but whether from a bag, special shop or Remy's they still aren't available all the time. So we have no way to obtain them on a semi-regular basis.. which is the point I'm trying to make. If the special shops aren't going to be around and all we have is the Black Market, I'd like to see the event items available in the bags during the appropriate events.
Crafting items 'are always available if you take the time to obtain them'.. I will be trying to max out my crafting items the hard way, so I can avoid spending gold on bags and just getting crafting items that I don't want. I will however be spending my gold on the parentless ammit hybrids in this BM. 80k is still a lot tho and I'm under 250k.. I've gone down a ranking in the wealth bracket now and it only took 17 days. If that isn't proof that prices need to come down, I don't know what is.