MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Teach, learn, and share work in the visual medium

Moderator: Hall of the Arts Moderators

User avatar
sparkpaw
MagiStream Donor
Member of Artificer's Association Member of Preservationists Association
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1326
Joined: October 30th, 2011, 8:46:23 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Lost
Contact:

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by sparkpaw »

Spectre wrote:I think it looks pretty good, I can't draw at all even though my mother is an AMAZING artist, I just didn't get her talent xD
My mother draws horses far better than me- I can draw what she can with a reference, but it's all in her head. For me, I got almost no talent- but I worked hard at what I've gotten to. I've been drawing seriously for about 3 years now, practice can be a great way to get you somewhere. :)
My father draws trees really well, and my brother does amazing concept cars- but no one but me pursues their talent, which is ironic since everyone else has talent and I've just got the dedication. >.<

Point being- if you want to learn to draw badly enough, you'll find a way to learn. ^_^
User avatar
sparkpaw
MagiStream Donor
Member of Artificer's Association Member of Preservationists Association
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1326
Joined: October 30th, 2011, 8:46:23 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Lost
Contact:

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by sparkpaw »

Updated with a new picture! ^___^
User avatar
fennelstar
Member of The Dark Brotherhood
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1039
Joined: November 3rd, 2011, 11:04:09 pm
Gender: Female
Location: On the Computer...

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by fennelstar »

I love the look in that gryphon's eye... very very nice work sparkpaw.
I am sadly behind on art, so if I owe you something (whether free or paid), please PM me! Also if you want to do and art trade, buy my art, or anything, PM me :D My dA is here: http://fennelstar.deviantart.com/gallery/
...

Image[/url]ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
User avatar
sparkpaw
MagiStream Donor
Member of Artificer's Association Member of Preservationists Association
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1326
Joined: October 30th, 2011, 8:46:23 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Lost
Contact:

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by sparkpaw »

Thank you dear :3
User avatar
EternalFox
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 8052
Joined: January 31st, 2012, 4:53:02 pm
Gender: Female
Location: O.o

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by EternalFox »

Well it looks really good... the lines look nice and natural, it's jut that the coloring of the gryphon doesn't give enough detail or texture, so it looks rushed. That's about it though, I love the lineart for both pieces so far.



•Fox is looking for RPs!•

ImageImage



Avatar and sig by YiTangMuLang
User avatar
Platypoose
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1375
Joined: May 6th, 2012, 1:18:55 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Avoiding digital art-wrecking, tablet-bumping cats.
Contact:

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by Platypoose »

Love the gryphon. Some more texture in the coloring would make it a lot better. I like the shape and the lineart!
Image
On a semi-hiatus, will be more active in the summer.
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Shop//Art Shop//Keep Cleaning//
Image
NeamaWolf
Member of The Herbalist's Guild
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 622
Joined: August 18th, 2012, 1:21:24 am
Gender: Kraken
Location: Behind you

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by NeamaWolf »

Very nice :D

The gryphon looks pretty good, but if you want my 2 cents of input, I'd agree with everyone else about the shading and texture on it. Don't be afraid to make your shadows darker and your highlights lighter, since right now it look pretty flat. Also when doing highlights, I wouldn't use white, I'd use something like yellow to make it pop out more. Try to avoid doing black and white values on a colored picture, it just flattens the image. You could use blue or purple for the shadows. The only possible exception is when doing a creature that is greyscaled, but even then you can use colors to make it pop out more. Blue is always a nice choice. The wings also look a little bit funky, I think its because the middle is rather long and the ends are too short. But I'm not very experienced in drawing folded wings so my suggestion may be a little wrong :P

As for the kirin, its look good so far! My only input is that if you can see the far ear (the right one) than you should be able to see the other antler (kirins have 2 antlers...right?). The anatomy looks pretty spot on to me, and the lines are nice and crisp :)

Keep up the good work! :woo:
ImageImage
"Flying is learning how to hurl yourself at the ground and miss."
User avatar
EternalFox
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 8052
Joined: January 31st, 2012, 4:53:02 pm
Gender: Female
Location: O.o

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by EternalFox »

NeamaWolf wrote:Very nice :D

The gryphon looks pretty good, but if you want my 2 cents of input, I'd agree with everyone else about the shading and texture on it. Don't be afraid to make your shadows darker and your highlights lighter, since right now it look pretty flat. Also when doing highlights, I wouldn't use white, I'd use something like yellow to make it pop out more. Try to avoid doing black and white values on a colored picture, it just flattens the image. You could use blue or purple for the shadows. The only possible exception is when doing a creature that is greyscaled, but even then you can use colors to make it pop out more. Blue is always a nice choice. The wings also look a little bit funky, I think its because the middle is rather long and the ends are too short. But I'm not very experienced in drawing folded wings so my suggestion may be a little wrong :P

As for the kirin, its look good so far! My only input is that if you can see the far ear (the right one) than you should be able to see the other antler (kirins have 2 antlers...right?). The anatomy looks pretty spot on to me, and the lines are nice and crisp :)

Keep up the good work! :woo:
Oh, that's what looked weird about the wing... I couldn't place it, but yeah. Also, kirins are considered "Japanese unicorns" so they only have one antler. It's kinda like the substitute for a horn on a unicorn, so yes, there's only one.



•Fox is looking for RPs!•

ImageImage



Avatar and sig by YiTangMuLang
NeamaWolf
Member of The Herbalist's Guild
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 622
Joined: August 18th, 2012, 1:21:24 am
Gender: Kraken
Location: Behind you

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by NeamaWolf »

EternalFox wrote: Oh, that's what looked weird about the wing... I couldn't place it, but yeah. Also, kirins are considered "Japanese unicorns" so they only have one antler. It's kinda like the substitute for a horn on a unicorn, so yes, there's only one.
Oh, I see! Then please ignore that comment of the other antler XD *needs to pay attention to species details more*
ImageImage
"Flying is learning how to hurl yourself at the ground and miss."
User avatar
sparkpaw
MagiStream Donor
Member of Artificer's Association Member of Preservationists Association
CreaturesTrade
Posts: 1326
Joined: October 30th, 2011, 8:46:23 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Lost
Contact:

Re: MS Fan Art - Critique wanted!

Post by sparkpaw »

EDIT: Also- so if I fix up the shading a bit, would you guys be willing to buy them as pets? And for how much gold? 5,000-10,000g?


Thanks everyone for the nice and constructive comments!!! ^_^
NeamaWolf wrote:Very nice : D

The gryphon looks pretty good, but if you want my 2 cents of input, I'd agree with everyone else about the shading and texture on it. Don't be afraid to make your shadows darker and your highlights lighter, since right now it look pretty flat. Also when doing highlights, I wouldn't use white, I'd use something like yellow to make it pop out more. Try to avoid doing black and white values on a colored picture, it just flattens the image. You could use blue or purple for the shadows. The only possible exception is when doing a creature that is greyscaled, but even then you can use colors to make it pop out more. Blue is always a nice choice.
Well it is greyscale, and tbh I wanted to do just a flatish color first. (And to be honest I'm not the biggest fan of these gryphons. XD) But maybe if I can force myself to look at them only a little more, and shade them more properly, it would be worth it. So I'll see.
NeamaWolf wrote:The wings also look a little bit funky, I think its because the middle is rather long and the ends are too short. But I'm not very experienced in drawing folded wings so my suggestion may be a little wrong :P

Keep up the good work! :woo:
As for the wing- I actually used a reference- somewhere on google. *shrug* and that's how it looked. I didn't want to bother with it too much not just cuz I'm not a fan of the piece and it hurts to look at it; but also because my non-referenced wings have always been difficult.

Otherwise- thank so much for the advice!! X D

I might try redrawing it entirely by drawing a first sketch on paper- where I'm much more at home and can do better sketchwork. X D
Post Reply

Return to “Hall Of The Arts”